SAR Filing Checklist: Pre-Filing Quality Review
SAR Filing Checklist: Pre-Filing Quality Review
Overview
This comprehensive checklist is designed to ensure that Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) are complete, accurate, and meet all regulatory requirements before filing. Use this checklist for every SAR to maintain high quality standards and ensure maximum value to law enforcement.
Purpose:
- Verify SAR completeness
- Ensure accuracy of information
- Confirm narrative quality
- Check timeline compliance
- Validate documentation
- Reduce filing errors
How to Use:
- Complete this checklist for every SAR before filing
- Address any items marked “No” before filing
- Obtain supervisor approval after checklist completion
- Maintain completed checklist with SAR documentation
Part I: Subject Information Verification
Subject Identification (Individual)
- Full legal name provided (first, middle, last)
- All known aliases or “doing business as” (DBA) names included
- Date of birth verified
- Social Security Number (SSN) or Tax Identification Number (TIN) included
- Complete current residential address (street, city, state, ZIP)
- Previous addresses included (if relevant to activity)
- All available phone numbers (home, mobile, work) included
- All known email addresses included
- Driver’s license number and issuing state provided
- Passport number and country included (if applicable)
- Occupation or employment listed
- Employer name and address (if applicable)
Subject Identification (Entity)
- Complete legal name of entity
- All DBA names or trade names included
- Employer Identification Number (EIN) provided
- Business address (physical location) included
- Mailing address (if different from business address)
- Type of business/industry specified
- State and date of incorporation
- Phone numbers and email addresses
- Website address (if applicable)
- Names of principals, owners, officers listed
- Names of authorized signers included
- Beneficial ownership information (if available)
Multiple Subjects
- All subjects involved in suspicious activity identified
- Each subject has complete identifying information
- Relationships between subjects explained
- Subject roles in suspicious activity described
- Primary subject clearly identified
Account Information
- All account numbers involved listed
- Account types specified (checking, savings, loan, etc.)
- Date(s) account(s) opened
- Date(s) account(s) closed (if applicable)
- Branch location where account opened
- Account purpose as stated by customer
- Names of all authorized signers
- Beneficiaries listed (if applicable)
Part II: Suspicious Activity Information
Activity Dates and Amounts
- Activity date or date range is accurate
- Start date reflects when suspicious activity actually began (not when detected)
- End date reflects last date of suspicious activity in this SAR
- Date range is reasonable and clearly explained in narrative
- Total dollar amount is correct
- Amount represents aggregate of all related suspicious transactions
- Aggregation methodology is documented
- Amount matches narrative description
Activity Categories
- All applicable activity type checkboxes selected
- Most specific categories chosen (not just “Other”)
- Categories accurately reflect the suspicious activity
- Multiple categories selected if activity involves multiple types
- At least one category checked
Common Categories:
- BSA/Structuring/Money laundering (if applicable)
- Check fraud (if applicable)
- Consumer loan fraud (if applicable)
- Credit card fraud (if applicable)
- Defalcation/Embezzlement (if applicable)
- Elder financial exploitation (if applicable)
- Identity theft (if applicable)
- Terrorist financing (if applicable)
- Wire transfer fraud (if applicable)
- Other (specify in narrative)
Instruments Involved
- All instrument types involved checked
- Cash (if applicable)
- Check(s) (if applicable)
- Wire transfer(s) (if applicable)
- ACH (if applicable)
- Debit card (if applicable)
- Credit card (if applicable)
- Money order (if applicable)
- Funds transfer (if applicable)
- Other (specified)
Critical Indicators
- “Continuing Activity” box checked if this is a continuing SAR
- Prior SAR BSA ID number(s) entered (if continuing activity)
- “Subject is insider” box checked if insider involvement
- Insider role specified (director, officer, employee, agent)
- Law enforcement request box checked (if applicable)
- FinCEN request box checked (if applicable)
- Corrects prior SAR box checked (if applicable)
Part III: Financial Institution Information
Institution Details
- Legal name of institution correct
- TIN/EIN correct
- Primary federal regulator correctly identified
- Type of financial institution correct
- Complete address provided
- EIN/TIN matches institution records
Filing Institution Role
- Filing institution’s role properly identified
- “Filing institution is subject” (if institution is victim)
- “No account involved” (if applicable)
- Proper role selected from available options
Joint Filing (if applicable)
- Joint filing clearly indicated
- All participating institutions identified
- Lead filer designated
- Other institutions’ information documented
Part IV: Contact Information
Primary Contact
- Contact office name provided
- Contact office address complete
- Contact phone number correct and current
- Contact person’s name included
- Contact person’s title provided
- Date SAR was prepared entered
- Contact information is for appropriate BSA/AML personnel
- Contact person has knowledge of the case
- Contact information will remain current
Alternate Contact (if applicable)
- Alternate contact provided
- Alternate contact information complete
- Alternate has knowledge of the case
Part V: Narrative Quality Review
Opening and Summary
- Opening sentence clearly summarizes the suspicious activity
- Type of suspicious activity stated upfront
- Subject identified in opening
- Time period stated in opening
- Total amount stated in opening
- Opening is concise (1-3 sentences)
The 5 W’s - Completeness
WHO:
- All subjects identified with complete information
- Subject roles explained
- Victims identified (if different from subjects)
- Other relevant parties described
- Relationships between parties explained
WHAT:
- Specific transactions described in detail
- Transaction types specified (deposits, wires, checks, etc.)
- Dollar amounts provided (not vague descriptions)
- Instruments identified (cash, wire, check, etc.)
- Methods described
- Pattern explained
WHEN:
- Specific dates provided for key transactions
- Chronological timeline clear
- Date range of pattern specified
- When activity was detected stated
- Timeline of investigation included
WHERE:
- Branch locations specified
- Geographic locations of transactions
- Countries involved (if international)
- ATM locations (if applicable)
- Online/mobile banking indicated (if applicable)
WHY:
- Clear explanation of why activity is suspicious
- Red flags explicitly identified
- Deviation from expected activity explained
- Comparison to customer profile provided
- Lack of legitimate business purpose stated
- Regulatory/typology references (if applicable)
Narrative Structure and Quality
- Narrative is well-organized and logical
- Paragraphs are focused (one topic per paragraph)
- Information flows chronologically or logically
- Uses headings or clear transitions between sections (if complex case)
- Length is appropriate (sufficient detail without unnecessary information)
- Plain English used (no unnecessary jargon)
- Active voice predominates
- Professional, objective tone maintained
Customer Profile and Background
- Account opening date and circumstances described
- Stated purpose of account included
- Expected account activity based on customer profile
- Customer’s occupation or business type
- Income sources (stated or known)
- Prior account history relevant to the activity
- Relationship with institution described
Transaction Details
- Specific transaction details provided
- Representative examples included (for patterns)
- Key transactions described individually
- Transaction amounts are specific (not vague)
- Dates are specific (exact dates, not “recently”)
- Frequency and patterns explained
- Counterparties identified
- Source and destination of funds (when known)
Red Flags and Indicators
- Specific red flags identified and listed
- Each red flag explained
- Combination of factors described
- Industry-standard red flags referenced (if applicable)
- FinCEN advisory indicators cited (if applicable)
- Typology match described (if applicable)
Investigation and Due Diligence
- Investigation steps described
- Enhanced due diligence conducted explained
- Database searches documented (LexisNexis, World-Check, etc.)
- Internet research described
- Customer contact attempts documented
- Customer’s responses (or non-responses) included
- Timeline of investigation provided
- Who conducted investigation identified
Customer Statements and Explanations
- Customer statements included (if any)
- Responses to inquiries documented
- Changes in explanations noted
- Evasive behavior described
- Refusals to provide information documented
- Inconsistencies in statements highlighted
Comparison to Expected Activity
- Expected activity based on profile described
- How actual activity deviates from expectations
- Significance of deviation explained
- Why activity is inconsistent with customer’s business/income
- Why activity lacks apparent lawful purpose
Institutional Actions
- How activity was detected (monitoring system, employee report, etc.)
- Date of initial detection
- Account actions taken (restrictions, closure, etc.)
- Enhanced monitoring implemented
- Prior SARs filed on subject (with BSA ID numbers)
- Communications with customer (without disclosing SAR)
- Current account status
Continuing Activity (if applicable)
- Prior SAR(s) referenced by BSA ID number
- Summary of initially reported activity provided
- Continuing activity described in detail
- Comparison to prior pattern
- Cumulative amounts stated
- Changes or escalation noted
- 90-day review documented
Conclusion
- Summary of basis for filing
- Overall assessment of suspicious activity
- Aggregate impact stated
- Ongoing concerns noted (if applicable)
- Conclusion is supported by facts in narrative
Writing Quality
- No spelling errors
- No grammatical errors
- No typos
- Sentences are clear and complete
- Punctuation is correct
- Formatting is consistent
- Numbers and dates are accurate and consistent
Content Appropriateness
Avoid These Prohibited Elements:
- No reference to the fact that a SAR is being filed
- No legal conclusions (“This is money laundering,” “Customer is guilty”)
- No speculation without factual basis
- No irrelevant personal information
- No discriminatory language or basis
- No subjective character assessments
- No information about ongoing law enforcement investigations
- No proprietary detection methods revealed
- No excessive or unrelated documentation described
Include Only Appropriate Content:
- Only facts and observations included
- Only relevant information included
- Objective tone maintained
- Facts support conclusions
Timeline Compliance
Filing Deadlines
- Initial detection date documented
- Filing deadline calculated correctly
- For identified subject: Filing within 30 calendar days of initial detection
- For unidentified subject: Filing within 60 calendar days of initial detection
- If continuing activity: Filing within 90 days of prior SAR
- Deadline is being met (not late)
- If late, reason documented internally
Continuing Activity Timelines
- Prior SAR filing date verified
- 90-day review date calculated correctly
- Review conducted timely
- If continuing SAR required, filing by 90-day deadline
Supporting Documentation
Required Documentation Available
- Account opening documentation
- Customer identification documents
- Transaction records (statements, tickets, images)
- Wire transfer records and instructions
- Check images (front and back)
- Deposit/withdrawal documentation
- Investigation work papers
- Database search results
- Internet research documentation
- Customer communications (letters, emails, notes from calls)
- Management approval documentation
Documentation Organization
- Supporting documentation organized and labeled
- Documents easily accessible
- File contains all relevant documentation
- Irrelevant documentation removed
- Confidential information protected
Retention Readiness
- File ready for 5-year retention
- File organized for easy retrieval
- Electronic and paper files coordinated
- Backup copies secured
Form Accuracy and Consistency
Internal Consistency
- Part II dates match narrative dates
- Part II amount matches narrative amount
- Subject information in Part I matches narrative
- Activity categories in Part II match narrative description
- All dates are internally consistent
- All amounts are internally consistent
- Account numbers consistent throughout
Data Accuracy
- All names spelled correctly and consistently
- All dates in correct format (MM/DD/YYYY)
- All amounts in correct format (no symbols, commas in right places)
- All addresses complete and accurate
- All phone numbers in correct format
- All identification numbers correct (SSN, EIN, account numbers)
Form Completion
- All required fields completed
- No fields left blank that should be filled
- Optional fields completed where information available
- Form will accept submission (no validation errors)
Regulatory Compliance
Threshold Compliance
- Activity meets or exceeds applicable dollar threshold ($5,000 or $25,000)
- Or: No dollar threshold applies (insider abuse, terrorist financing, etc.)
- Aggregation is appropriate and documented
- Subject identification determination is correct
Insider Abuse (if applicable)
- Insider role specified
- No dollar threshold applied (correctly)
- Insider status clearly explained in narrative
- Breach of duty or trust described
Terrorist Financing (if applicable)
- Filed immediately (not waiting for 30-day deadline)
- FinCEN hotline contacted (if appropriate)
- OFAC screening conducted
- If OFAC match, blocking requirements followed
Special Situations
- If joint SAR: All institutions identified, coordination documented
- If correcting prior SAR: Original SAR referenced, corrections explained
- If law enforcement request: Request documented
Quality Control
Internal Review
- Preparer reviewed SAR for completeness
- Self-review checklist completed
- Spelling and grammar checked
- Facts verified against source documents
Supervisory Review
- Supervisor/reviewer assigned
- Supervisor reviewed for quality
- Supervisor verified compliance with requirements
- Supervisor provided feedback (if needed)
- Revisions made based on feedback
- Supervisor approved for filing
Final Checks
- All checklist items addressed
- Any “No” responses resolved or explained
- Narrative read one final time
- Form completion verified
- Supporting documentation complete
- Ready to file
Pre-Filing Final Review
Critical Elements - Final Verification
The following are the most critical elements. Verify one final time before filing:
Subject(s) identified with maximum available identifying information
Narrative clearly explains WHY the activity is suspicious
Part II dollar amount is correct and matches narrative
Part II date range accurately reflects suspicious activity period
Activity categories correctly selected
Continuing activity properly indicated (if applicable) with prior SAR referenced
Insider involvement indicated (if applicable)
Timeline deadline will be met
Narrative contains no prohibited disclosures (no reference to SAR filing)
Supporting documentation is complete and organized
Supervisor has approved
Ready to file via BSA E-Filing
Post-Filing Requirements
Immediately After Filing
- Download and save SAR acknowledgment
- Verify BSA Identification Number received
- Record BSA ID number in case management system
- Print or save PDF of acknowledgment
File Organization
- Filed SAR saved to permanent file
- Acknowledgment saved with SAR
- Supporting documentation filed
- Completed checklist filed
- Investigation work papers filed
- Case file labeled with BSA ID number
Case Management System Updates
- BSA ID number entered in system
- Filing date recorded
- Case status updated to “Filed”
- Next action date entered (if continuing activity, enter 90-day review date)
- Case assigned for ongoing monitoring (if appropriate)
Notifications (if appropriate)
- Senior management notified (if significant case)
- Account officer notified of account actions (without disclosing SAR)
- Enhanced monitoring team notified
- Fraud team notified (if fraud case)
Checklist Sign-Off
SAR Details:
- Subject Name: _________________________________
- Account Number(s): _________________________________
- Activity Type: _________________________________
- Activity Amount: _________________________________
- Activity Date Range: _________________________________
Checklist Completion:
Prepared By: _____________________________ Date: __________
Title: _____________________________
Reviewed By: _____________________________ Date: __________
Title: _____________________________
Supervisor Approval:
- Approved By: _____________________________ Date: __________
- Title: _____________________________
Filing Confirmation:
- Filed By: _____________________________ Date: __________
- BSA Identification Number: _____________________________
- Filing Date: __________
Common Filing Errors to Avoid
Top 10 Most Common Errors
Vague or incomplete narratives
- Ensure narrative provides specific details and clearly explains why activity is suspicious
Missing critical subject identifiers
- Include all available identifying information for subjects
Incorrect activity date range
- Part II should reflect when suspicious activity occurred, not when it was detected or investigated
Wrong dollar amount
- Aggregate all related suspicious transactions; don’t report only one transaction
Wrong activity categories selected
- Select most specific applicable categories, not generic “Other”
No explanation of “why” suspicious
- Clearly articulate red flags and why activity raises suspicion
Not indicating continuing activity
- Check continuing activity box and reference prior SAR(s) when applicable
Not indicating insider involvement
- Check insider box and specify role when subject is institution insider
Late filing
- File within 30 days (identified subject) or 60 days (unidentified subject)
Inconsistencies between Part II and narrative
- Ensure dates and amounts in Part II match narrative description
Tips for High-Quality SARs
Narrative Writing Tips
Do:
- Start with clear, concise summary
- Use specific dates and amounts
- Provide transaction-level detail when relevant
- Describe patterns clearly
- Include subject statements when relevant
- Note evasive behavior
- Reference prior SARs by BSA ID number
- Use active voice
- Use plain English
Don’t:
- Use vague terms (“various,” “multiple,” “several”)
- Include irrelevant personal information
- Make legal conclusions
- Include opinions about guilt
- Disclose SAR filing to subject
- Include speculation without facts
Investigation Tips
Before Filing:
- Complete thorough investigation
- Conduct enhanced due diligence
- Search relevant databases
- Review complete account history
- Document all findings
- Obtain supervisor review
Timeline Management Tips
Stay on Track:
- Document initial detection date immediately
- Calculate filing deadline immediately
- Set internal deadline 5-7 days before regulatory deadline
- Monitor deadline in case management system
- Escalate if approaching deadline without completion
Conclusion
This checklist is a tool to ensure high-quality, complete, and compliant SAR filings. Use it for every SAR to:
- Reduce filing errors
- Ensure completeness
- Maintain quality standards
- Meet regulatory requirements
- Provide maximum value to law enforcement
- Support regulatory examinations
- Demonstrate thorough process
Remember: High-quality SARs protect the financial system, support law enforcement, and demonstrate your institution’s strong BSA/AML program.
Checklist Version: 2.0 Last Updated: May 8, 2024 Next Review Date: May 8, 2025
This checklist is for internal use as a quality control tool. Adapt to your institution’s specific procedures and requirements. Consult with legal counsel and compliance professionals for institution-specific guidance.
